Silky Oak and White Oak: two Grevilleas that get confused constantly
Two trees get sold in Queensland as silky oak, and a third carries the name in the far north. The pair that get confused constantly are Grevillea robusta and Grevillea baileyana. They are not substitutes for one another. One is a big, fast, brittle forest tree with a long list of complaints attached to it, and the other is a compact, dense, well mannered thing that most people asking for a silky oak would be happier with.
Grevillea robusta is a forest tree and behaves like one
Its natural range runs through south east Queensland and northern New South Wales, on river flats and rainforest margins, and it makes a tall tree on a straight trunk. The leaves are finely divided and fern-like, grey-green above and silver beneath. The flowers are the golden orange one-sided racemes everyone knows, carried in quantity, full of nectar, and worth watching for the birds they bring in.
The problems all follow from the speed. It grows fast, and fast growth here means comparatively low density wood. Limbs shed in summer storms, and they shed worst on trees that have been headed back at some point, because regrowth from a cut is attached to the outer wood only and gets heavier every year. It also drops leaves under drought stress, so the tree thins out in exactly the summer you wanted shade from it. Flower fall is heavy and sticky. Leaf fall is constant, and the fine leaflets travel.
Then there is the dust. Anyone who has milled or sanded silky oak treats it with respect: the sawdust is a genuine irritant to skin and airways and sensitivity builds with exposure. That is more a timber trade matter than a garden one, but it is worth knowing before you put one where it will be cut regularly.
None of this makes it a bad tree. It is tough, it handles dry, it grows in poor country and it feeds birds. It is a bad tree in the wrong place, and the wrong place is most suburban blocks.
Grevillea baileyana keeps better company
White oak comes from wet tropical rainforest in Far North Queensland, on a restricted natural range, in country much like our farm at Utchee Creek. Almost everything about it is different. The leaves are simple and entire rather than divided, glossy dark green above, and the reason to grow it is what happens underneath: new growth flushes copper, and the leaf backs carry a rust bronze felt that catches the light every time the wind turns them over. The flower spikes are cream to white, and what falls from them is far less trouble on the ground below.
The crown is denser and more compact, and it stays furnished low down where light reaches the lower branches. That is the quality that makes it useful in a screen. Silky oak will not do it. Silky oak lifts its skirt and leaves you a trunk with the canopy a long way up.
It has its own conditions. It is frost tender while young, so at Ravensbourne it wants a protected position rather than a frost hollow, and it does not enjoy long dry spells. Where it is warm and there is moisture it is close to trouble free.
Which one belongs where
- In a garden: baileyana, as a feature with room to fill out, or a corner tree with planting run through the base.
- In a screen: baileyana again, in a row with real spacing rather than crammed in as a hedge. Density comes from light reaching the lower branches, so leave the gaps.
- In neither: robusta. It belongs in open country: a paddock, a shelter line, a large park, a rural driveway with paddock either side. Somewhere the litter lands on grass and a shed limb hits nothing.
Do not put a silky oak over a pool, a driveway, a car park, a footpath or a roof with gutters, and do not put either of them under powerlines. Where the line is the constraint, that is a different search entirely, and the powerline friendly trees are where it starts.
What decides it on your site
Four questions, in this order.
- Frost. How cold does the low corner get, and is the tree going into it? Robusta is hardier once established. Young baileyana is not.
- Water. Is there irrigation, or is it rainfall and optimism? Baileyana wants moisture and rewards it.
- What sits underneath. Grass forgives litter. Paving, pools, parked cars and gutters do not.
- Room. Not the space available now, the space in twenty years, above ground and below it.
There is one more consideration that people skip. Silky oak is often chosen because it is quick, and quick is the wrong criterion when you are buying an advanced tree in the first place. If you want size, buy size. Speed after planting buys you brittle wood.
If you are weighing these two against each other, or against something else that does the same job, the Australian natives are the place to start, and choosing your size is worth reading before you settle on a specimen. Send us the site rather than the species and we will tell you what we would plant there.