The Journal · November 2026

Cyclone season and a large tree: what helps, and why topping makes next season worse

Cyclone season and a large tree: what helps, and why topping makes next season worse

From November to April in the Far North the advice about storm pruning gets loud, and a good deal of it arrives with a chainsaw attached. The most common version, take the top out of it so the wind can get through, is wrong for a large tree, and wrong in a particular way: it makes the following season worse rather than better.

Topping does not make a tree safer

Cutting a canopy back to stubs does three things at once. It leaves large wounds on wood that has no way to seal them, so decay works down into the stub. It removes most of the leaf area the tree lives on, when it most needs to be building fine roots. And it triggers a flush of shoots from dormant buds around each cut, which grow fast, grow dense, and are attached to the outer layers of wood rather than anchored into the branch.

By the next season you have a denser canopy than you started with, catching more wind, standing on stubs that are quietly rotting. The failures that follow are bigger pieces breaking lower down. Topping trades a small risk this year for a larger and lower one every year after, and it is not reversible. A topped tree can be worked back towards a reasonable structure over years, but it does not come back to what it was.

Heavy crown reduction and aggressive thinning are gentler versions of the same trade. Stripping the interior out of a canopy so the wind passes through, sometimes called lion tailing, shifts the leaf weight to the ends of long bare limbs and takes away the growth that damps movement. It looks tidy. It is a mechanical downgrade.

What genuinely improves the odds

Structure, built over years, mostly with small cuts:

  • One dominant leader. Two stems of equal size meeting in a tight fork with bark trapped between them will fail eventually, and a cyclone decides when. Correct it while the stems are small enough for a handsaw.
  • Dead wood, hanging limbs and broken stubs out of the canopy before the season.
  • Load kept in from the ends. Shorten an over-extended limb back to a suitable side branch, never into a stub.
  • Palms nearby cleared of loose dead fronds, which travel a long way in wind.
  • Nothing new trenched through the root zone. A service run cut across a root plate is a failure point months later.

The ground matters as much as the canopy. Large trees that go over in a cyclone often do not break. They lean, because the soil is saturated and the root plate works free. That points at drainage, at not stacking fill over the root flare, and at keeping traffic off the root zone all year.

Ties, mulch and the loose things under the canopy

  • Ties. Check them at the start of the season and after every blow. Firm enough that the ball is not rocking, slack enough that nothing bites into bark, and no bare wire against the trunk anywhere. Take stakes and ties off once the tree is holding itself, because forgotten hardware girdles.
  • Mulch. 75 mm deep, held clear of the trunk, in a ring rather than a mound. Mulch heaped against a trunk keeps bark wet and rotting, and a mound washes and floats in cyclonic rain. The doughnut, not a volcano.
  • Loose material. Star pickets, spare stakes, timber offcuts, pots, bins, furniture, sheets of mesh. All of it becomes a projectile, and a bark wound from flying steel does not go away.

A tree that went into the ground with its ball intact and its basket around it has its stability underground where it belongs. The basket holds the ball together while roots grow out through it, the hessian rots and the wire degrades. Stakes and ties are a supplement to that, not a substitute for it.

Afterwards, do less than you want to

The morning after a big blow the instinct is to tidy up. Slow down.

  • A tree leaning with its root plate partly lifted can often be stood back up and re-anchored while the soil is still soft, provided the trunk and the flare are sound. Once the soil sets around it, that option closes.
  • Torn branches want a clean cut back to a proper union or to the branch collar. Not a flush cut into the trunk, not a stub, and no wound paint.
  • Defoliation is not death. A tropical tree stripped of leaves will usually reflush. Water it once the ground drains, and leave the saw alone until you can see what survived.
  • Heavy nitrogen straight after damage pushes soft growth the tree cannot support. Water and seaweed extract are the sensible response.

Access matters too. Roads in the north get cut, and a crane cannot reach a site that is under water.

Trees grown in cyclone country

Our northern farm is at Utchee Creek near Innisfail, in the same weather as most of the sites we send trees to. The trees there grow in open ground and are root pruned in stages through their production life, which builds a dense fibrous root system in close rather than a few long anchors. The north face of every root ball is marked before the tree leaves the ground, so it can be planted facing the sun exactly as it grew. None of that makes a tree cyclone proof. It means the parts that matter arrive intact, and the rest is site work and patience.

If you have a large tree on an exposed northern site and you are unsure what should come out of it, the honest answer is that it depends on the structure of that tree, and the way to find out is to have somebody competent look at it before the season rather than after. There is more about how the trees are grown at Donkin Farm, and you are welcome to get in touch about a site.